contact +44 (0)131 669 5190 - e-mail

CIPR Accredited Practitioner
PHPR animated banner


Thursday, 18 April 2013

PHPR welcomes Supreme Court decision to protect internet users from "over-reaching copyright collectors"

Edinburgh PR agency PHPR on PRCA and NLA news monitoring decision
Press releases are a key part of  PHPR's service to get clients noticed in the media and online 
Edinburgh-based PR agency, PHPR welcomes today's news that the Supreme Court has supported all of the arguments made by the PRCA (Public Relations Consultants' Association) against the NLA (Newspaper Licensing Authority) re browsing online articles without infringing copyright law. It will now refer the case to the Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU) so that this point can be clarified across the entire EU.

Francis Ingham, PRCA Chief Executive says, "The PRCA is very proud to have stood up on behalf of the whole PR industry for the last few years. We are delighted that the highest court in the country accepted our argument outright."

Penny Haywood Calder, founder of PHPR says,"It beggers belief that the Newspaper Licensing Agency Ltd (NLA) thought it could charge for looking at a web page online if it included newspaper articles and passing on a link to an article: something millions of people probably do all over the world every day. It is particularly galling as the NLA is extracting cash from the PR industry and their clients, despite us alerting journalists to many potential stories and often bending over backwards to give them access to senior executives for quotes and comment. To charge us for checking to see what a publication had done with that input is, in my opinion, ridiculous. 

"The introductory NLA license is for a small agency of up to 5 people serving just three clients. In our experience, we have to run more than 3 clients a year per consultant to break even, and it places us in an impossible situation if we get a spate of one-off launches and other ad hoc work. We are too small to risk falling foul of the rules, so we just suggest to clients that they make their own arrangements to see results. It is galling when our client knowledge gives us the ability to go into each and every online news search in more granular detail than would be possible with a general monitoring brief involving a third party."

According to the PRCA, the Supreme Court said that the NLA’s position would be “an unacceptable result, which would make infringers of many millions of ordinary users of the internet across the EU who use browsers and search engines for private as well as commercial purposes."

Penny Haywood Calder added, "I have been online since 1985 in the heady pioneer days of acoustic coupled modems running at unbelievably slow speeds. I've watched online forums rules develop to balance the fundamental freedoms of the internet against the need to curb abuse, then watched as users developed individual codes of practice and social media policies. In nearly 28 years online, I have never seen anything as blatant as this attempt by the NLA to curtail online freedom. 

"As a small business owner, I felt powerless to do anything. All credit to the PRCA and Meltwater that they have stuck with this battle. A battle that, in my opinion, should not have had to be fought. The only winners in this long drawn out battle would appear to be the lawyers, which in the current economic climate is not good news for entrepreneurial and ground-breaking newsworthy businesses and their PR support teams."

Jorn Lyssegen, CEO of Meltwater said: “We are very pleased that the Supreme Court overruled the previous rulings of the Court of Appeals and The High Court that the simple act of browsing the Internet could be copyright infringement. This ruling is an important step in modernizing the interpretation of UK copyright law and protects UK Internet users from overreaching copyright collectors.”

Penny Haywood Calder adds, "It's not yet over for PR agencies who the PRCA advises to keep paying NLA fees as "a precautionary measure" until next year when the Court of Justice of the European Union is expected to report. 

PHPR is an Edinburgh-based PR and online marketing agency founded by Penny Haywood Calder in 1986 and incorporated as PHPR Ltd in 1999. The agency now specialises in B2B, technology and small businesses. PHPR has come through three recessions and spends up to a third of its time actively learning about new outlets and practical tools to effectively help develop clients' businesses on and offline. PHPR is an award winning agency and a VIBES finalist - Scotland's top environmental award for business. 

PR blog posted by Penny Haywood Calder at PHPR Ltd, Edinburgh, UK. URL: PHPR TV Channel on YouTube: PHPR Ltd on LinkedIn Follow PennyHaywood on Twitter

Labels: , , , ,

posted by Penny Haywood Calder at


Bookmark and Share



Post a Comment

Subscribe to Post Comments [Atom]

<< Home